ICP by evidence, not anecdote
Sellers describe an ICP. Diligence confirms one. The distance between those two statements is where the value-creation plan either lives or dies.
Every CIM has an ICP slide. Roughly one in five survives diligence intact.
The right test is mechanical. Take the last twenty-four months of closed-won logos, segment by industry, headcount band, geography, and use case. The ICP is whatever the data says it is, not whatever the founder describes in management meetings.
When the stated ICP and the observed ICP diverge, the divergence itself is the most important finding in the diligence memo. It usually predicts where the sales motion has to be rebuilt post-close.
Why stated ICPs drift
Founders describe the customers they are proudest of, which are often the largest or most recognisable logos. The revenue base is frequently built on a different, less glamorous segment that buys faster and churns less. Both descriptions are honest; only one is useful for underwriting.
Building the observed ICP
Segment closed-won deals by industry, headcount band, geography and use case, then add sales cycle length, first-year value and twelve-month retention for each segment. The segments that combine short cycles, healthy value and strong retention are the real ICP, regardless of where the marketing budget goes.
Checking against lost deals
Lost deals test the edges of the ICP. If the team repeatedly loses in a segment the CIM calls core, that segment is aspirational. Five or six lost-deal conversations are usually enough to see the pattern.
Using the gap in the value creation plan
A clear gap between stated and observed ICP gives the post-close plan a concrete first move: point marketing and sales capacity at the segment that already converts, and treat the aspirational segment as a later, separately funded bet.
What we'd do this week
Request the closed-won file for the last twenty-four months, segment it by the four fields above, and compare the top segment against the ICP slide in the CIM. If they differ, put that difference at the top of the diligence memo.