A working commercial diligence checklist for lower-middle-market PE
What to evidence before LOI, what to confirm during exclusivity, and which questions almost always show up after close. Built for operating partners running parallel deals.
Most commercial diligence checklists are imported from large-cap playbooks and then quietly ignored once a real lower-middle-market deal lands on the desk. The result is a memo that reads tidy and a 100-day plan that reads chaotic.
This is the working version we use ourselves: thirty-eight items split across market, ICP, pricing, channel, retention, and competitive defensibility, each tagged with whether it must be answered pre-LOI, during exclusivity, or in the first ninety days.
The pre-LOI subset is deliberately small. The point at screening is not to confirm the thesis, it is to identify the two or three commercial assumptions that, if wrong, would change the bid. Everything else moves to confirmatory.
Inside exclusivity, the goal flips: the bid is set, and the question becomes whether the operating model survives contact with reality. That means evidence on win rates by segment, real pricing realisation versus list, sales cycle by buyer type, and the quality of the existing pipeline coverage.
The B2B version of that evidence set is narrower than most teams expect, because much of it comes down to whether closed-won looks like the stated ICP. We keep the commercial due diligence checklist for B2B targets as a separate list for that reason, with the segment and pricing items broken out.
The list above is only the commercial half of confirmatory work; the codebase, the data model, and the revenue engine are the technical half of the same question, and they are usually taken on trust. After close, the same checklist becomes the spine of the operating cadence. Items that were inferred during diligence become initiatives owned by named executives with KPIs and a date.
Running 38 items across parallel deals is where most teams run out of hours rather than judgement. Our guide to AI due diligence for private equity covers which parts of that list a model can evidence and which still need an operator on a call.
Market: the five items that set the bid
Market items are the ones most often over-researched and under-used. Before LOI we want five answers: the definition of the served category in the buyer's words, the count of qualifying buyers in the core geography, the growth rate of that count rather than of spend, the two or three substitutes a buyer considers, and whether the category is consolidating or fragmenting. Anything beyond that is confirmatory work.
ICP and customer concentration
The ICP section should be answered from closed-won data, not from the CIM. We ask for the last twenty-four months of logos with industry, headcount band, geography, first-year contract value and current ARR. Concentration is read from the same file: top ten customers as a share of revenue, top customer as a share, and whether any single buyer persona drives more than half of new bookings.
Pricing and packaging
Pricing items cover list versus realised price, discount depth by segment and quarter, renewal uplift history and the shape of the packaging ladder. In lower-middle-market software and services, realised price is typically 15-30% below list; the useful question is whether the gap is stable, widening or controlled by a named policy.
Channel, retention and pipeline
Channel items test where new revenue actually comes from: inbound, outbound, partners, founder network, or referrals. Retention items separate gross from net, logo churn from contraction, and cohort behaviour from blended averages. Pipeline items test coverage against the forecast and whether stage definitions mean the same thing in every region.
Competitive defensibility
The last block asks why customers stay. Switching costs, integration depth, data gravity and service quality are the usual answers. We evidence each with at least two customer references and one lost-deal conversation, because won-deal references alone overstate defensibility.
What we'd do this week
Take the checklist, mark every item as pre-LOI, exclusivity or post-close for the deal in front of you, and cut the pre-LOI list to no more than eight items. Those eight are the questions that decide the bid; the rest can wait for the data room.